Here's Everything You Need to Know to Bake a Homemade Pie

2015-06-09
Here's Everything You Need to Know to Bake a Homemade Pie

A homemade pie is always sure to be a showstopping dessert, and it doesn't have to be complicated. In just five easy steps, you can make your own homemade piecrust from scratch, add your own filling, and bake. Our how-to guide will teach you everything you need to know about making and baking a piecrust, but if you're looking for more specific information, like what temperature to bake an apple pie or how long to bake a blueberry pie, it's best to pick one recipe and follow those instructions.

Step 1: Make the Piecrust

First, decide what type of piecrust you want to make—it depends at least in part on what you want the filling to be. For example, for most pumpkin and pecan pies, you'll want to learn how to make a single-crust piecrust. But for most fruit pies, like apple and cherry, you'll want to make a double-crust piecrust. Once you've chosen your recipe, follow these steps for success:

  • Use a pastry blender to cut shortening into the flour mixture. Work the mixture until the pieces are the size of small peas.
  • Sprinkle ice-cold water, 1 tablespoon at a time, over the flour mixture. Toss gently with a fork. Push to one side of the bowl.
  • Repeat until all of the flour mixture is evenly moistened. After the flour is moistened, use your hands to gently press and form the dough into a ball.

Step 2: Roll Out the Piecrust and Transfer It to a Pie Plate

For a lot of new bakers, transferring a piecrust to the pie plate without tearing, stretching, or breaking it can be a little tricky. But if you follow these instructions, it'll go just fine:

  • On a floured surface, use a floured rolling pin to roll out the dough from center to edge. Using light, even strokes with the rolling pin, form a 12-inch circle with an even thickness.
  • Wrap the piecrust around the rolling pin to transfer to the pie plate.
  • Holding the rolling pin over the pie plate, unroll the piecrust starting at one side of the pie plate.
  • Ease the piecrust into the pie plate without stretching it.
  • Lightly press the piecrust into the bottom and up the sides of the pie plate.

Step 3: Shape the Edges

You can learn how to give your piecrust a special edge if you want, or you can keep it simple:

  • Use kitchen scissors or a small knife to trim the excess dough to 1/2 inch beyond the edge of the pie plate.
  • Build up the edge of the pie shell by folding the extra 1/2 inch of pastry under so it is even with the rim of the pie plate.
  • To crimp the edge (give it a fluted shape), place a finger against the inside edge of the piecrust. Use the thumb and index finger of your other hand to press the piecrust around your finger. Continue around the full circumference of the pie plate.

Step 4: Add the Filling and Bake

Now comes the fun part—making your filling and baking your pie! You can turn your piecrust into a luscious apple pie recipe or a super-juicy berry pie. Just follow these steps:

  • Stir together the filling for your pie according to the recipe. Pour the filling into the unbaked piecrust—keep in mind that some recipes call for baking the piecrust before filling it, so be sure to double-check your recipe before adding the filling.
  • Preheat your oven so the pie bakes evenly. To prevent overbrowning, cover the edge of the pie with foil, loosely molding the foil over the pie's edge.
  • Carefully transfer your pie to the oven, being careful not to spill liquid filling over the edge of the crust (if it's a single-crust pie).
  • Wondering how long to bake a pie or what temperature to preheat your oven to? It's always best to follow your recipe closely, because different pie fillings can have different baking times and temperatures (you can typically count on the temperature being between 350°F and 375°F). Remove the foil and bake 20 to 25 minutes more or as directed by your recipe.

Step 5: Test for Doneness

One of the most important parts of making a homemade pie is testing it when it comes out of the oven to make sure it's done (and we don't mean taste-testing). There are different tests for different pies, so follow these instructions when your pie comes out of the oven:

  • Cream and custard pies are done when a knife inserted near the center comes out clean.
  • Fruit pies are done when the filling is bubbly and the top crust is golden brown.
  • Cool your pie on a wire rack. Some pies—like custard and cream pies—need to be stored in the refrigerator. Other pie recipes are best served warm, so be sure to follow your recipe's serving and storing instructions.

Related Article

Red Curry Tofu Skewers

Red Curry Tofu Skewers

Tofu, eggplant, and mushrooms soak up the ginger-curry marinade like mini sponges, infusing them with fresh Thai flavors.
24 of Our Favorite and Most Delicious Classic Italian Recipes

24 of Our Favorite and Most Delicious Classic Italian Recipes

Start with classic Italian pasta recipes and end with a homemade dessert like you'd get in a trattoria for the ultimate Mediterranean meal.
This Smoked Mole-Inspired Turkey Is Juicy and Flavorful

This Smoked Mole-Inspired Turkey Is Juicy and Flavorful

For this smoked turkey recipe, we concocted a rub using spices typically found in a traditional Mexican mole (a rich chocolate-chili sauce), including cocoa, cinnamon, cumin, and chili powder. If you don’t have a smoker, you can still use the warm spice combo on a roasted turkey.
Crispy Tofu "Stir-Fry"

Crispy Tofu "Stir-Fry"

This easy stir-fry recipe is healthier than most—instead of actually frying the tofu, make it in your air-fryer instead! It'll be just as crispy as frying it oil, but much healthier for mixing with veggies and rice.
Fruit Leather

Fruit Leather

Fruit Leather
Can You Eat Salmon Skin? Yes—And Here’s the No. 1 Secret to Cooking it Properly

Can You Eat Salmon Skin? Yes—And Here’s the No. 1 Secret to Cooking it Properly

Not all seafood is enjoyable skin-on, so you might be wondering, “can you eat salmon skin?” You sure can, but it’s important to employ a few simple strategies to ensure it’s golden-brown and crispy (rather than rubbery). We’ll walk you through how to cook salmon skin—both on the fish and off as a makeshift “chip.”
Blueberry Oat Chia Seed Muffins

Blueberry Oat Chia Seed Muffins

These sweet mini muffins are delicious and surprisingly healthy! Get your day started off on the right note with these blueberry muffins that come with a few health upgrades (including oats and chia seeds).
Asian-Style Sweet Potatoes

Asian-Style Sweet Potatoes

Make-ahead side dish magic: Prep and roast the sweet potatoes and broccoli up to three days ahead. Once you're ready to eat, all that's left to do is reheat, toss with dressing, and serve.
Cauliflower Steaks with Hazelnuts and Browned Butter

Cauliflower Steaks with Hazelnuts and Browned Butter

Finish this caramelized cauliflower with a rich brown butter and hazelnut pan sauce.
Spicy Tempeh Bulgogi

Spicy Tempeh Bulgogi

A sweet sesame-soy marinate makes infuses plant-based tempeh (fermented soybean cake), making a delicious Asian-inspired vegan meal.
Tombstone Taco Dip

Tombstone Taco Dip

Refried bean dirt, shredded lettuce grass, and tortilla tombstones and trees take chip dip to Halloween territory.
4 Must-Haves for a Self-Serve Margarita Bar Guests Will Love

4 Must-Haves for a Self-Serve Margarita Bar Guests Will Love

Impress your guests with this party-ready margarita bar—complete with a variety of garnishes, rimmers, and boozy stir-ins for customized cocktails.
Healthy Sandwich Ideas That Rival Your Favorite Deli Order

Healthy Sandwich Ideas That Rival Your Favorite Deli Order

Our healthy sandwich ideas include everything for eating well, from healthy sandwich meat to fresh veggies. This portable meal can be good for you.
The Best Methods and How Long to Marinate Chicken for Tasty Meals

The Best Methods and How Long to Marinate Chicken for Tasty Meals

Learn the best ways and how long to marinate chicken using our two easy methods for the tastiest meals you'll make again and again.
Oven-Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Oven-Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Make roasted Brussels sprouts in your oven! Toss with apples, cherries, and pecans for an irresistible 20-minutes vegetable side.
Buffalo Chicken Quesadillas

Buffalo Chicken Quesadillas

Buffalo chicken and gooey cheese? Count us in. Serve this scrumptious buffalo chicken recipe with carrots and celery to help make it a fresh and filling meal.
Lemon-Caper Tuna and Noodles with Alfredo

Lemon-Caper Tuna and Noodles with Alfredo

Calling for just five simple ingredients, this 20-minute pasta recipe is one of the easiest dinner recipes that has even come out of our Test Kitchen. Brighten things up just before serving by topping with a handful of chopped chives.
Farro-Stuffed Peppers

Farro-Stuffed Peppers

Farro-Stuffed Peppers
12 Gluten-Free Breakfast Recipes That Will Be Morning Staples

12 Gluten-Free Breakfast Recipes That Will Be Morning Staples

Gluten-free breakfast recipes might seem hard to come by, but we've got options. Here you'll find recipes for gluten-free pancakes and more.
Eggplant "Meat" Balls with Chimichurri

Eggplant "Meat" Balls with Chimichurri

Enjoy these plant-based meatballs for your next meatless dinner.